Green Book 2022 for appraisal to support better decisions making

  • Home
  • How to use Green Book 2022 for appraisal to support better decisions for business cases.

How to use Green Book 2022 for appraisal to support better decisions for business cases.

HM Treasury’s The Green Book provides instructions on how to evaluate policies, programmes, and projects. Additionally, it offers advice on the planning and correct employment of monitoring and evaluation before, throughout, and after execution.

The Green Book is not an automated or predetermined system for making decisions. Instead, it offers accepted thinking models and methodologies to clarify the costs, advantages, and trade-offs of multiple solution strategies for achieving policy objectives.

The fundamental aspect of any business case is the appraisal or evaluation of costs and risks, which decides whether the project/proposal is excellent value for money. One of the valuable features of the Green Book is that it lays down the foundation of fundamental processes for decision-making to help policymakers and decision-makers choose the option that will successfully achieve social and economic objectives.

What is Appraisal?

The process of evaluating the costs, advantages, and hazards of substitute methods to achieve governmental objectives is called appraisal. Giving decision-makers an unbiased evidence foundation helps them understand the potential outcomes, trade-offs, and overall effects of decisions.

In social value appraisal, also known as public value, the focus is on economic market efficiency and overall social welfare efficiency. It, therefore, encompasses not only market effects but also all significant costs and benefits that impact the safety and welfare of the population.

Rationale for Intervention

Justifying intervention is the first phase of appraisal. The Green Book provides comprehensive information on the rationale for intervention, so the concerned person can understand how to reason and come up with logical reasons for intervention. The first stage of the two-stage appraisal process involves considering a long list of choices and choosing a logical and practical group of possibilities for shortlisting analysis. Furthermore, the framework for relevant alternatives and the filter procedure used for shortlist selection and longlist analysis are explained in detail.

The Main Evaluation Steps

Making a case for change includes the Strategic Assessment, quantifying the current situation, Business as Usual (the BAU), and defining SMART objectives. Defining what is to be appraised begins with this rationale. This guidance explains that meeting SMART objectives is essential for completing the Five Case Model process.

Longlist analysis with the choices framework filter considers the most effective way to accomplish the SMART objectives. To eliminate prejudice toward predetermined approaches that have not been thoroughly evaluated, choices are viewed through the prism of public service supply. Numerous options are considered, and a workable shortlist is chosen that includes the preferred course of action. These are continued for a more thorough evaluation. The key to developing the best value-for-money proposals likely to provide results that are pretty close to expectations is this approach, where all complicated factors are considered.

Shortlist appraisal, which comes after and forms the core of comprehensive appraisal and in which anticipated costs and benefits are calculated, and trade-offs are taken into account; the Strategic, Commercial, Financial, and Management components of the five case models are all closely related to this research and cannot be produced or evaluated separately. In addition, social Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA) or Social Cost Effectiveness Analysis (CEA) is used when considering costs and benefits.

Appraisal’s Function

A project’s feasibility must be evaluated before moving forward, so policymakers are incentivised to do so. A minimum quality standard can be maintained by requiring business case approval to meet a specific bar.

Assessment and appraisal aim to offer unbiased insight to assist in decision-making. The Treasury Approval Process, the Regulatory Impact Assessment process, and the review of business cases by authorising bodies in government departments and other public organisations are all parts of the decision-support process. When formal business cases and regulatory decisions are not necessary, the alternative analysis should also be supported by the Five Case Model and the methodologies and principles of the Green Book.

What Can I Understand From The Green Book?

  • Analyse and implement the Five Case Model’s guiding principles when creating business cases and other spending recommendations.
  • Know what business cases are, what they are for, who is responsible for them, and when they are needed.
  • Learn the connections among the five instances and the business case development lifecycle.
  • Create solid spending plans and business justifications for the effort to secure funds and management support.

What Should You Really Do?

This advice should be implemented in a balanced manner. Resources and effort should be allocated following the costs, advantages, and risks the proposals may pose to society and the public sector. Furthermore, as a critical component of all planned interventions, monitoring and evaluation of all ideas should be incorporated into all key proposals’ budgets and management plans.


The goal of the intervention must be stated explicitly. This is referred to as the justification, and in the central government, ministers or other decision-makers decide the general policy objectives. To accomplish the aforementioned goals, officials should find and create alternative solutions. Therefore, advice must be founded on unbiased analysis and viable alternatives.

The justification should detail how the suggested delivery alternatives will bring about the desired changes in outcomes. For example, the proposition’s goal could be to:

  • Preserve service continuity due to the requirement to replace a component of the current delivery method.
  • To increase service delivery efficiency.
  • To provide a more significant quantity or higher quality of service.
  • To offer a new service.
  • To adhere to legislative changes.
  • Policymakers may frequently use a combination of all of these.

Policy Development

The development of the justification for a policy must come first, and it must be founded on a thorough knowledge of the current situation. To properly comprehend the magnitude and important characteristics of the problems, they need to be comprehended in terms that can be objectively quantified.

This is how Green Books help policymakers reach the most accurate decision for any business case under consideration. The Green Book provides comprehensive guidelines for the fundamental processes required to make a decision backed up by rationale. It provides guidance on each step, for instance, how to design, carry out the appraisal process, be rational, develop policy, etc. Remember, all these steps eventually help in effective cost management for a project.

leave a comment